MeyerFire
  • Blog
  • Daily
  • Exam Prep
    • CFPS Tools
    • NICET Tools
    • PE Forum & Errata
    • PE Problems
    • PE Store
    • PE Tools
    • PE Prep Series
  • TOOLS
    • TOOLKIT (FREE TRIAL)
    • *TOOLKIT (PURCHASE)
    • SUBMIT AN IDEA
    • BACKFLOW DATABASE*
    • CLEAN AGENT ESTIMATOR
    • CLOUD CEILING CALCULATOR
    • DOMESTIC DEMAND
    • FIRE PUMP ANALYZER
    • FIRE PUMP DATABASE*
    • FIRE FLOW CALCULATOR*
    • FRICTION LOSS CALCULATOR
    • HANGER SPACER
    • IBC TRANSLATOR*
    • K-FACTOR SELECTOR
    • NFPA 13 EDITION TRANSLATOR ('19 ONLY)
    • NFPA 13 EDITION TRANSLATOR ('99-'19)*
    • LIQUIDS ANALYZER*
    • OBSTRUCTION CALCULATOR
    • OBSTRUCTIONS AGAINST WALL*
    • PLUMBING FIXTURE COUNTS
    • REMOTE AREA ANALYZER
    • QUICK RESPONSE AREA REDUCTION
    • SPRINKLER DATABASE*
    • SPRINKLER FLOW*
    • TEST & DRAIN CALCULATOR
    • THRUST BLOCK CALCULATOR
    • TRAPEZE CALCULATOR
    • UNIT CONVERTER
    • VOLUME & COMPRESSOR CALCULATOR
    • WATER SUPPLY (US)
    • WATER SUPPLY (METRIC)
  • CODE CALLS
  • LOGIN
  • STORE
  • About
Picture
A FORUM FOR FIRE PROTECTION QUESTIONS & PE EXAM PROBLEMS | SUBSCRIBE NOW

Why Suction of Fire Pump Needs 10 Diameters?

6/29/2020

31 Comments

 
We have a fire pump room which is very constrained. 

NFPA 20 (Edition 2016), A.4.21.1.2 (2) For horizontal split-case fire pumps, there should be a distance of not less than 10 diameters of suction pipe for side connection (not recommended) to the fire pump suction flange.

The main pumps have a capacity of 3000 gpm (two are electrically-driven and two are diesel-driven) with two jockey pumps at 300 gpm capacity. All are in one room. Pumps suction and discharge pipe  size is 12" as per Table 4.27 (a).

In this scenario, what is the meaning of 10 diameters - is it 10 times of suction size diameter of pump (means 10x12= 120") or something else?

Why is this requirement only limited to suction and why not for discharge side as there is tapping for pressure monitoring? Any thought would be much appreciated.

Submitted anonymously and posted for discussion. Discuss This | Submit Your Question | Subscribe
31 Comments
Wayne Ammons
6/29/2020 08:03:44 am

The purpose for the 10x distance is to prevent turbulent flow from entering the fire pump and impeller which can cause wear and cavitation over time. If your suction size is 12 inch, you will need 120 inches from the fitting flange to the pump suction flange or suction fitting flange, depending on the configuration. Figure A.4.15.6 of NFPA 20, 2016 edition shows example diagrams to better explain this.

Reply
Jim Mernickle link
6/29/2020 10:11:07 am

Does the same hold true for all suction pipe sizing's ? So that a 4" feed pipe would require 40" of straight pipe before the pump and no fittings (90's, 45's etc) in that 40" space ?

Reply
Casey Milhorn
6/29/2020 10:28:28 am

So the 10 pipe diameters, from memory, only applies to backflow preventers and fittings that are at a right angle in a horizontal plane to the suction of the pump. If your underground lead-in is lined up with the fire pump and your only change of direction is in a vertical orientation, you can have less than 10 pipe diameters. Vertical changes in direction don't cause nearly the same type of issue as a horizontal change in direction due to the way gravity affects the fluid moving through the piping. Horizontal changes of direction cause the water to rotate and have the possibility for turbulence and air pockets.
If you absolutely have to make a horizontal change in direction, you can always add some vertical piping up and back down to meet the 10 pipe diameter rule.

Louie Lincoln link
6/29/2020 10:46:20 am

10 x the pipe diameter related to the length of the proposed pipe the length has to be at least 1X the diameter of the proposed pipe. I have seen a pump that was piped directly in from the side.
The pump shaved 1/2 of the impeller off. An impeller would cost tn the range of $5K-$20k.

Reply
Thomas Jones
6/29/2020 11:27:19 am

As mentioned, it is for turbulence. One thing I have done in tight pump rooms is create a "n" shape. So from your incoming line go up than change direction down for 10x the pipe diameter.

Reply
Shaikh
6/29/2020 11:43:18 am

If there is case where o & Y gate valve has to be included within this 10 times pipe dia of suction, Do we need to exclude this length of O & Y gate valve.

Reply
Frank link
6/29/2020 04:02:10 pm

SHAIKH, the 10 diameters are measure from the flagelo of the OS&Y Valve to the suction flange.

Reply
Nguyen Thong Nhat
6/29/2020 09:06:43 pm

Disagree, 10 x Diameter requirement apply only for tee and elbow, or any fitting that cause water turbulent in suction pipe, OS&Y valve isn't one of them.

Franck
6/30/2020 02:08:42 pm

If OS&Y valve is provided, no need to maintain this 10 x diameter as there is no obstruction, i.e. no turbulence, within the pipe when the valve is open.
If you have a gate valve (which is normally not permitted per NFPA on suction side... but can still be seen from time to time) or a backflow preventer or any other equipment, then you need to maintain a safe distance of 50 ft, whatever the size of your suction piping.
The 10 x diameter requirement is only for tee or elbow that are horizontally perpendicular to the plane of the fire pump. No need for vertically perpendicular (NFPA 20 has good drawings explaining what is correct and what is wrong).

Frank link
6/29/2020 04:03:36 pm

the Jockey puma shall be 30 GPM not 300 GPM, please check this capacity.

Reply
Sunil kumar
6/30/2020 11:54:42 am

Jockey pumps requirements are based on local client preference, so it is 300 gpm in this case.

Reply
Shahad
10/13/2020 05:03:08 am

Technically, the jockey pump capacity should be less than the flow from any sprinkler head in the system. In the event of fire, Primary fire pump MUST turn on. This is one of the reason why NFPA doesn't mandate jockey pumps to be listed, as its function should be limited to maintain the pressure in the system.

Nguyen Thong Nhat
6/29/2020 08:52:06 pm

...there "should" be... It's mean you can follow or not follow it. Because Fire pump often run in a short time, so, if your pump room is small, you can pass this requirement. You also can find the explain that why it's should be 10x Diameter in ANSI/HI 9.6.6 figure 9.6.6.3.3b

Reply
Nimal Tissa Wijetunga
6/30/2020 07:41:47 am

Disagree. 10 pipe diameter is a requirement as per NFPA and FM Global.

Besides, there cannot be a small pump room and tight space and all these because take the pump orientation and the space requirement for other functions, you never have tight space in the pump room.

Reply
Nguyen Thong Nhat
6/30/2020 09:40:33 pm

Yes, I think there is an error of word in that requirement. it must be "shall" instead of "should", as shown in 4.16.6.3.1 and 4.16.6.3.2 (NFPA 20-2019 ed.). By the way, there are many commercial building having a small area for pump room that seldom seen in industry building, and they also needn't the FM approval.

Franck
6/30/2020 02:10:54 pm

This is a reliability issue.
Many AHJ or Insurance Companies will anyway not accept this wrong arrangement.
I will not for a new installation !
You will have early ageing of your impeller and pump characteristics degradation over a short-medium term.

Reply
koray uluç
6/30/2020 03:01:11 am

The concern for 10 pipe diameter straight line requirement is not turbulence nor cavitation. it is for the differential pressure occurrence on each side of the pump impeller. That is why it is not required for end suction pump but required for horizontal or vertical split case pump only.
Additionally on split case pump installations, elbows that are close to impeller but vertical to impeller shaft are not need to be far away from the suction flange as described on NFPA 20.
While working, continuous pressure difference on sides of the impeller cause damage on impeller bearings.

Reply
Franck
6/30/2020 02:14:11 pm

end suction pumps are normally not allowed by NFPA, only horizontal split case pumps (more robust and more reliable).

End suction pumps are anyway often used in Europe.
I don't think that any of them is UL listed or FM approved (but maybe I am wrong).

Reply
koray uluç
7/1/2020 01:36:32 am

Sorry, but this is a wrong info

Franck
7/1/2020 01:50:43 am

As often, I was too much self confident and the information I put was wrong (end suction pumps can be FM approved and UL listed). Mostly based on my European experience where such pumps are very often provided, and almost never UL listed or FM approved.
Thanks for the correction Koray.

Nithin Babu
6/30/2020 06:58:22 am

If space is constrain in pump room, then the requirement of 10 D can be satisfied by introducing diffuser, i remember victualic offer such diffuser

Reply
Jeva
10/7/2020 07:18:23 am

Hi can I know the type of diffuser.

Reply
Franck
6/30/2020 02:19:28 pm

In addition to all the above comments, your question was also "why we don't have the same requirement on the discharge side ?".
The reason is that on the suction side you create turbulence and differential pressures on the impeller shaft that could deteriorate the pump characteristics over the time.
On the discharge side, you can't damage the fire pump. This is why there is no such requirement for a minimum distance between the discharge side of the fire pump and the backflow preventer, for example.

Reply
Drew Lange link
6/30/2020 04:31:32 pm

The Minnesota State Fire Marshal used to publish a great one-page newsletter named "Quick Response." The June 2008 issue covered Fire Pump Suction Piping Arrangement. It can be found at the link below. Keep in mind the NFPA 20 references were from a previous version of NFPA 20.

https://dps.mn.gov/divisions/sfm/programs-services/Documents/Quick%20Response%20Newleter/QR0608FirePumpsSuctPipe.pdf

Reply
Nimal Tissa Wijetunga
6/30/2020 10:46:29 pm

Within that 10 Pipe diameter distance, only OS&Y Gate Valve is allowed and this 10 pipe diameter is to get laminar flow to the impeller from the suction side and it is definitely a requirement.

Reply
JUHWAN KANG
7/1/2020 01:50:19 am

Could you inform where can I find any clause for that OS&Y Gate Valve is allowed within 10D?

Reply
Franck
7/1/2020 04:31:05 am

NFPA 20 (Last Edition)
§ 4.16.5.1 OS&Y should be provided on the suction side
§A.4.16.5 OS&Y should be located as far as feasible from the flange when suction supply is from public fire main, but there is no strict distance limitation. And no limitation if from a private reservoir.
§ 4.16.5.4 No other valve type or other approved device should be located at less than 50 ft
§ 4.29.3 check valve and backflow preventer are allowed at 10 D (or 50 ft if butterfly valves are isolating the backflow preventer)

The 10 D limitation in § 4.16.6 is for tee and elbows only.

Nimal Tissa Wijetunga
7/1/2020 10:27:15 am

Dear Franck,

Your information above is totally wrong.

Reply
Joe Meyer
7/1/2020 11:21:36 am

Nimal, you need to reply in the correct string and also comment specifically about what your concerns are. This forum is for fostering discussion.

Joe

Reply
Franck
7/1/2020 11:38:56 am

Dear Nimal
I always like to learn from my mistakes (and I make some from time to time)
Could you please give more details on what is wrong on the information?
Many thanks in advance

Reply
cy
7/1/2020 11:19:04 am

You can review the section for suction diffuser, which according to the NFPA 20 ed 2019 is equvalent to the 10 pipe diameter of straight pipe. Bue review the equivalent pressure loss for this device and check with the manufacturer the installation requirements

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Jump to: Daily Posts
    Jump to: PE Problems
    Picture
    Why Sponsor?

    Free Signup

    Subscribe and learn something new each day:
    I'm Interested In:

    Community

    Thank You to Our Top
    ​October '20 Contributors!
    1. SK
    2. Franck
    3. Dan W.
    4. Jonathan ​5. Casey M.
    6. Sean
    7. Colin L.
    8. Mike
    9. Jonathan J
    ​10. Daniel G.


    Your Post

    SUBMIT A QUESTION

    The Toolkit

    Sprinkler Designer or Engineer?
    ​
    ​Get all of our tools, including the Sprinkler Database, Friction Loss Calculator, Fire Pump Analyzer and more:
    Picture
    FREE 30-DAY TRIAL
    GET THE TOOLKIT

    Filters

    All
    ABA
    ADA
    ASCE 7
    ASME A17.1
    Daily Discussion
    Design Documents
    Explosion Protection & Prevention
    Fire Detection And Alarm Systems
    Fire Dynamics
    Flammable & Combustible LIquids
    FM Global
    Human Behavior
    IBC
    IFC
    Information Sources For Analysis
    IRC
    Means Of Egress
    NFPA 1
    NFPA 10
    NFPA 101
    NFPA 11
    NFPA 110
    NFPA 12
    NFPA 13
    NFPA 13D
    NFPA 13R
    NFPA 14
    NFPA 15
    NFPA 17A
    NFPA 20
    NFPA 2001
    NFPA 214
    NFPA 22
    NFPA 24
    NFPA 25
    NFPA 291
    NFPA 30
    NFPA 33
    NFPA 400
    NFPA 415
    NFPA 497
    NFPA 5000
    NFPA 502
    NFPA 54
    NFPA 55
    NFPA 70
    NFPA 72
    NFPA 92
    NICET
    Passive Building Systems
    PE Prep Guide
    PE Prep Series
    PE Sample Problems
    Poll
    Smoke Management Systems
    Special Hazard Systems
    Types Of Analysis
    UFC 3 600 01
    UFC 3-600-01
    Updates
    Water Based Fire Suppression
    Weekly Exams


    Archives

    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    November 2016
    October 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    June 2015


    Daily
    Daily discussions are open-ended fire protection, fire alarm, and life safety questions submitted anonymously for the benefit of sharing expertise and learning from other perspectives. Anyone can submit a question here:
    SUBMIT A QUESTION

    Exam Prep

    Picture
    2020 PE Prep Guide​
    ​(Available Now!)
    Picture
    PE Prep Series
    ​(Available Now!)
    2020 PE Prep Series
    Current Leaderboard
    ​(Click to enlarge)
    Fire Protection PE Exam Prep

    PE Problems
    ​Visit July-October for daily Fire Protection PE Exam sample questions.

    Solutions are posted the day after posting.

    Comment with your solutions, questions or clarifications.

    Please note that questions posted are unofficial and in accordance with NCEES rules are intended to be similar to actual exam questions, not actual exam questions themselves.

    RSS Feed

Home - About - Blog - Contact - Exam Prep - Store
Picture
Copyright © 2020 MeyerFire, LLC
The views, opinions, and information found on this site represent solely the author shown and do not represent the opinions of any other party, nor does the presented material assume responsibility for its use. Fire protection and life safety systems constitute a critical component for public health and safety and you should consult with a licensed professional for proper design and code adherence. Some (not all) outbound links on this website, such as Amazon links, are affiliate-based where we receive a commission for orders placed elsewhere.
  • Blog
  • Daily
  • Exam Prep
    • CFPS Tools
    • NICET Tools
    • PE Forum & Errata
    • PE Problems
    • PE Store
    • PE Tools
    • PE Prep Series
  • TOOLS
    • TOOLKIT (FREE TRIAL)
    • *TOOLKIT (PURCHASE)
    • SUBMIT AN IDEA
    • BACKFLOW DATABASE*
    • CLEAN AGENT ESTIMATOR
    • CLOUD CEILING CALCULATOR
    • DOMESTIC DEMAND
    • FIRE PUMP ANALYZER
    • FIRE PUMP DATABASE*
    • FIRE FLOW CALCULATOR*
    • FRICTION LOSS CALCULATOR
    • HANGER SPACER
    • IBC TRANSLATOR*
    • K-FACTOR SELECTOR
    • NFPA 13 EDITION TRANSLATOR ('19 ONLY)
    • NFPA 13 EDITION TRANSLATOR ('99-'19)*
    • LIQUIDS ANALYZER*
    • OBSTRUCTION CALCULATOR
    • OBSTRUCTIONS AGAINST WALL*
    • PLUMBING FIXTURE COUNTS
    • REMOTE AREA ANALYZER
    • QUICK RESPONSE AREA REDUCTION
    • SPRINKLER DATABASE*
    • SPRINKLER FLOW*
    • TEST & DRAIN CALCULATOR
    • THRUST BLOCK CALCULATOR
    • TRAPEZE CALCULATOR
    • UNIT CONVERTER
    • VOLUME & COMPRESSOR CALCULATOR
    • WATER SUPPLY (US)
    • WATER SUPPLY (METRIC)
  • CODE CALLS
  • LOGIN
  • STORE
  • About