When would you recommend replacing an existing fire pump?
I am working a project where we are renovating a large hotel and the diesel fire pump in the basement is dated 1994. I am aware there is a lifespan but with proper maintenance they can probably operate just fine for a long time. Is 30 years when you would begin to suggest replacing that piece of equipment? Should I make the suggestion to the client that it is best to replace and have them make the final call? Thank you. Sent in anonymously for discussion. Click Title to View | Submit Your Question | Subscribe
9 Comments
Pete H
10/23/2023 06:45:31 am
30 Years is usually more than enough time to recommend replacing one in terms of the item's "lifespan". The lifespan can vary from type of pump to type of pump (i.e. a vertical inline fire pump has a lifespan of about 7-15 years whereas a horizontal splitcase should last between 25-40.)
Reply
Anthony
10/23/2023 07:31:55 am
If its working I would not recommend replacing the pump unless there was clear wear and tear on the item. Something like an obvious rattle when its running coming from the pump.
Reply
Glenn Berger
10/23/2023 08:08:36 am
If the fire pump passes the inspection and testing protocols, then I would only put a bug in the ear of my client based upon the age of the equipment.
Reply
Jesse
10/23/2023 08:23:02 am
If the pump is showing signs of degradation I'd certainly be looking at replacing it
Reply
Franck
10/23/2023 10:12:46 am
As long as the fire pump gives acceptable results on the annual flow test curve and has been regularly maintained, there is no need to change it.
Reply
Casey Milhorn
10/23/2023 11:19:26 am
From a legal perspective, I would say it depends on your role in this project.
Reply
Anthony
10/23/2023 11:53:37 am
I have worked on many "old" fire pumps in New York City Hotels. I have never had to request a replacement but did on several occasions require overhaul, mostly on the driver. If the pump has been churned, tested, and maintained correctly these pumps should last well beyond the manufacturer's life span date.
Reply
Dan Wilder
10/24/2023 07:26:38 am
Many excellent options above. From a ITM contractor side:
Reply
Cliff Schulze
10/24/2023 08:31:34 am
One other thing to consider that has not been addressed is the condition of the base. I've seen quite a few fire pump installations where the drip packing has been allowed to fall on to the base which over time corrodes it. A thorough inspection of the pump should be part of your consideration.
Reply
Leave a Reply. |
ALL-ACCESSSUBSCRIBESubscribe and learn something new each day:
COMMUNITYTop September '24 Contributors
YOUR POSTPE EXAMGet 100 Days of Free Sample Questions right to you!
FILTERS
All
ARCHIVES
November 2024
PE PREP SERIES |