I've come across this question - why do we need to flow more water - from two angles: as a total rookie, and later on as someone needing to really understand a water supply.
As a newbie - I was intimidated by a few things; first, that someone would call the police on me because I didn't look like I knew what I was doing. Second, that I didn't want to destroy any landscaping. And third, I definitely didn't want to be breaking any hydrants. Those three factors made me want to keep my flow tests as calm and low-flow as possible. However, as I was told at the time, that's not advantageous when we're trying to determine the quality of an existing water supply. Just a year ago, I was working on a project with a marginal water supply, where the water tower and the pumps feeding it were controlled by the project owner. The tower was in some disrepair (not known to us at the time), and we were trying to figure out why we were getting such different results from what should have been a fairly consistent supply. It was on this project where we really needed to understand the strength of the supply that was well beyond just 300, 400, or 500 gpm into the system. But why? Why does it matter if we flow 500 gpm or 1,000 gpm when doing a flow test? One perspective - and one answer to this - is confidence in the data. We gain more confidence in our test results with the greater amount of water we flow. Here's a video we put together that explains this perspective a little better:
Hope you have a great week!
Meg
2/2/2022 10:42:50 am
Well presented with easy to follow graphics. Thank you!
Blake Henderson
2/2/2022 10:56:18 am
Great video! Keep videos like this coming...
Drew King
2/2/2022 11:50:18 am
I concur, great video! We typically try to flow both 2-1/2" outlets when feasible. 500-1500 gpm is my comfort range. Getting up to 2000 gpm in a busy area is nerve-wracking. We use hose monsters which helps keep the water in the curb and also helps get a more stable pitot reading.
Matthew Foreman
2/3/2022 10:44:03 am
Yes. Great video and explanation!!
andre bourgoin
2/6/2022 08:18:25 am
Thanks nicely done, I always try to flow past the requirement for the project and to get 3 points on the graph, as you mentioned it's a more precise result
Alex
2/10/2022 05:49:39 am
Great video for not just new engineers, but any FPE that isn’t familiar with where the data points they use daily are coming from. It’s important to understand how to run these tests and what a typical curve looks like per region or town. This is useful to be able to spot possible errors within the results.
Dean L Melanson
2/16/2022 12:05:51 pm
Great video and great explanations, well done.
Dwight H Havens
2/16/2022 01:49:49 pm
Joe, Best explanation that I have seen. Kept simple but with a level of precision. Many folks do not have a clear understanding of the difference between interpolation and extrapolation. This provides it, and most importantly, the impact on the accuracy of the results.
Zane Jones
3/8/2022 10:21:38 am
Sharing to others and helping others understand such important details. Can't wait for more videos and explanations! 3/21/2022 04:54:13 am
Graphics are well-presented and simple to understand. Thank you so much! 4/19/2022 02:36:55 pm
Great Video, if the flow test is a point in time, how do you factor Season Adjustments (IBC code) or Seasonal Fluctuations as noted in NFPA 13?
Joe Meyer
4/19/2022 02:48:41 pm
The best way is to connect with the water purveyor, who (should) understand the demands of their system better than anyone. They may not always have the information, but they would be the best possible party that would understand how the single-snapshot would fit into their daily and seasonal fluctuations. Comments are closed.
|
ALL-ACCESSSUBSCRIBEGet Free Articles via Email:
+ Get calculators, tools, resources and articles
+ Get our PDF Flowchart for Canopy & Overhang Requirements instantly + No spam
+ Unsubscribe anytime AUTHORJoe Meyer, PE, is a Fire Protection Engineer out of St. Louis, Missouri who writes & develops resources for Fire Protection Professionals. See bio here: About FILTERS
All
ARCHIVES
November 2024
|