|
My coworker and I are disagreeing about townhomes.
Can each townhouse (3 total) have its own NFPA 13D system? Or do they need to have one total system? Each townhouse has a 1-hr separation in the form of UL U347. I cannot find anything that says they can't each have their own, but he is saying he can't find anything to say they can, to which I have always said if it doesn't say no, then it's usually allowed. Sent in anonymously for discussion. Click Title to View | Submit Your Question | Subscribe
18 Comments
Pete H
11/3/2025 06:11:31 am
You're both right.
Reply
pHILIP
11/6/2025 09:53:42 am
The answer is in the building code (2016, 2019, or 2022 code editions related to R-2 occupancies dealing with townhomes where each townhome is allowed up to 4 stories without standpipe because each townhome is being considered as designed for R-3 sprinkler protection. I believe there may have been a code change by now.
Reply
Brett
11/3/2025 06:47:29 am
Typically it's done by teeing off from the domestic water supply within each unit, but you could do it with a dedicated feed for the townhouse depending on how your local AHJ and local water authority require it to be setup.
Reply
Philip
11/6/2025 09:58:11 am
Control valve is prohibited between the domestic control valve and the sprinkler system. If the municipal water purveyor's main shutoff valve is closed, there will be no water supply to the house.
Reply
11/3/2025 07:26:52 am
We have adjacent AHJ's and one would allow one riser per building (for all 3 units), while the one across the street would require separate riser and feeds for each unit. This is based on the adopted and amended codes for per your AHJ.
Reply
11/3/2025 08:08:34 am
Because they are townhouses, they are separate BUILDINGS, not just separate units like apartments. As such, you need one system per building.
Reply
Ricardo Gonzales
11/3/2025 08:44:56 am
There are 2 trains of thoughts on this. 1: The Code restricts you to what you can do. or 2: The Code mandates what the minimum to be done. The premise of this discussion is valid both ways and how the AHJ was trained. Even in Law this conundrum occurs frequently. i.e. speed limits (thou shall not exceed) and how you parent (the minimum you need to do is:) Both are seen in the Codes as they are written because they work diligently to allow new technology with means and methods, while restricting some details or performane3 criteria.
Reply
Anthony
11/3/2025 09:42:18 am
I'd say it comes down to if there is an HOA. Though technically possible to run all units off a common system I would say its socially inadvisable unless there is a contractual agreement in place.
Reply
Ivan J Humberson
11/3/2025 10:51:40 am
I agree with Tim's response - if the units are on separate properties, then you could not have one system feeding across property lines. That being said, I have seen several "townhouse condominium" projects wherein there was a common sprinkler system serving multiple townhomes. In my humble opinion, that is a horrible arrangement - if you have an incident in one townhome that requires shut-down of the sprinkler system, then all the other townhomes are shut down. In such a situation, a fire watch would normally be required until the fire protection system is back in service, but how do you do a fire watch for townhomes?? It's just not a good arrangement, and separate systems are a much better approach.
Reply
Jack G
11/3/2025 11:07:27 am
Check with the AHJ.
Reply
Todd E Wyatt
11/3/2025 12:42:10 pm
The first step is determining WHAT the scoping Code is for the Project …. IBC vs IRC?
Reply
Todd E Wyatt
11/3/2025 12:42:34 pm
REFERENCES
Reply
Todd E Wyatt
11/3/2025 12:43:02 pm
REFERENCES
Reply
Jack G
11/3/2025 07:39:29 pm
Disagree with a lot of the above. Towmships, municipalities have alternates, substitutions to IBC, IRC, IFC. Have their own versions.
Reply
Jack G
11/3/2025 07:44:15 pm
And the outcome, when you ask the AHJ, could be there are amendments to follow, or code has not been amended, and they will list the code to follow…. to the letter.
Reply
chad
11/4/2025 12:00:19 pm
As most said, it depends. Some water departments/authorities will allow one connection to their system for the whole building's sprinkler, others want each unit separate if they are condo'ed. but if one owner, one system is ok.
Reply
Curtis Tower
11/4/2025 05:29:17 pm
When considerint arrangements such as this, I look at who is responsible for the fire sprinkler system over the life of the system/building. When townhomes are separately occupied, perhaps owned by different people, then I always lean toward individual systems. This negates the issue of one person being responsible for a single riser supplying an entire building and protecdting multiple families.
Reply
Leave a Reply. |
ALL-ACCESSSUBSCRIBESubscribe and learn something new each day:
COMMUNITYTop Oct '25 Contributors
YOUR POSTPE EXAMGet 100 Days of Free Sample Questions right to you!
FILTERS
All
ARCHIVES
November 2025
PE PREP SERIES |
RSS Feed
